Rebecca Henion This is a very good start on the first writing assignment. You have done an excellent job, for the most part, on the "they say" part. I have made a number of suggestions for rewording or rewriting things directly on a printout of the paper. Ask me what I meant if the markings are not clear. Comment: The major thing I think you might add is more detail about why Laskawy says "We’ve handed over the seed industry - and in a meaningful sense, the agricultural system - to a handful of large companies." I don't know if you are aware of this, but some of the business practices that the big agribusiness companies like Monsanto and Syngenta are using with GMOs are actually really extreme. For instance, when farmers buy seed for GMO varieties of a crop, they are in effect only leasing the seeds for one year by the way the companies have set up their business contracts. Any seed the plants produce that year remains the property of the business, and the farmers cannot use it to plant in following years. You say that GMOs are not providing benefits for farmers and this is one of the reasons. PS: One of the main points of the Laskawy article is that increased resistance to pesticides and herbicides is negating the benefits of GMO crops. The interesting point her is that that resistance develops naturally through evolution. In effect, the genomes of the pests and the weeds are changing in response to our genetic modification of the crops. Some people compare the situation to an arms race where neither side can ever gain a decisive advantage.